In 2014, a mysterious explosion of an interstellar meteor over the western Pacific Ocean caught the attention of Harvard astronomer Avi Loeb and his team, prompting them to embark on an ambitious fishing expedition to retrieve pieces of the meteor from outside our solar system. However, a new study led by Benjamin Fernando from Johns Hopkins University is casting doubt on the success of their mission.
Using a magnetic sled near Papua New Guinea in 2023, Loeb’s team claimed to have collected hundreds of millimeter-scale spherules from the meteor, dubbed IM1. Despite their findings, Fernando’s study suggests that the data used to determine the search area may have been flawed, with the vibrations detected likely caused by a road, not the meteor.
Additionally, Fernando’s team suspects that the fragments found during the expedition may be ordinary meteorites or particles mixed with terrestrial contamination, rather than true interstellar material. In response to these claims, Loeb defended the findings in a recent blog post, highlighting the unusual composition of the spherules enriched in beryllium, lanthanum, and uranium.
Despite the controversy, Loeb announced plans for another expedition to the drop zone in hopes of finding larger pieces of the meteor. The ongoing debate and conflicting opinions from scientists underscore the complexity of retrieving interstellar meteor fragments and the importance of continued research in the field.
As the scientific community awaits further analysis and validation of the findings, the success of this interstellar fishing expedition remains uncertain. Stay tuned to The Bib Theorists for updates on this developing story.
“Zombie enthusiast. Subtly charming travel practitioner. Webaholic. Internet expert.”